UT Institute for Geophysics

Understanding the Earth and other planets to solve key problems that affect us all. The world needs geophysicists!

  • About
    • Institutional History
    • Mission & Science
    • Code of Conduct
    • Job Listings
    • Postdoctoral Fellowships
    • Outreach
    • Contact
    • UT Austin Science Olympiad
  • News
    • Media Releases
    • Geophysics Blog
    • In the News
    • Staff and Student Awards
    • Media Contacts
  • Research
    • Climate
    • Polar and Planetary
    • Energy
    • Marine Geosciences, Seismology and Tectonics
  • Staff
    • Research Scientists
    • Postdoctoral Fellows
    • Administrative Staff
    • Scientific Support Staff
    • Research Affiliates
    • Find an Expert
  • Students
    • Current Students
    • Recent Graduates
    • Meet the UTIG Student
    • Prospective Students
    • UT Marine Geology & Geophysics Field Course
  • Seminars
  • COVID-19
    • JSG Coronavirus Updates
    • Give to UT’s Student Emergency Fund

Appendix B. Power Imbalances

At their best, scientific academies are where discovery and learning occur through a combination of diligent work and collaboration. However, the highly competitive and hierarchical structures of academia also create susceptibilities for abuse of power and bullying. The traditional graduate student model of working in a research specialty under the close supervision of a graduate advisor depends on good faith. Qualifications, such as seniority and supervisory capacity, endow certain individuals with greater authority to affect the career outcomes of their colleagues and students. The mission of the Institute requires that senior employees be invested in the learning and development of early career scientists and students. This requires diligence to avoid actions that may be perceived as bribery, coercion, malice, or indifference. Personal favors should never be proposed in exchange for advice, collaboration, or recommendation. Institute employees should act to prevent abuse of power with regards to:

  1. Letters of support and recommendation. The contents of letters of recommendation are often subjective and subject to bias. For example, one analysis of letters of recommendation for postdoctoral researchers showed that female scientists were significantly less likely to receive an excellent letter than a good letter compared to their male colleagues[1]. Letter writers must be diligent to prevent biases in their letters.
  2. Graduate student and postdoctoral advising. Practices such as co-advising may help limit the potential for abusive advising relationships.
  3. Performance review committees, including doctoral defenses and promotion reviews.
  4. Scientific collaborations.

<< Previous

Next >>


[1] Dutt, K., et al. Gender differences in recommendation letters for postdoctoral fellowships in geoscience. Nature Geosci 9, 805–808 (2016). https://doi.org/10.1038/ngeo2819.

Code of Conduct

  • Home
  • Section 1: Preface
  • Section 2: Conduct Expectations
  • Section 3: Active engagement
    • 3.1 Bystander intervention
    • 3.2 Complicating factors
    • 3.3 Thresholds: When to say (or do) something?
    • 3.4 Trainings available at UT Austin
  • Section 4: Reporting Mechanisms
  • Section 5: Informal Reactions
    • 5.1 Why internal reports and informal reactions?
    • 5.2 Multiple approaches to mediation and conflict resolution are needed
    • 5.3 Restorative justice model for conflict resolution
    • 5.4 Confidentiality
    • 5.5 Stalled mediation
  • Section 6: Formal Reactions
    • 6.1 Discrimination, Harassment, and Mandatory Reporting
    • 6.2 Fraud and Scientific Misconduct
  • Appendices
    • Appendix A. UTIG DEAI Committee
    • Appendix B. Power Imbalances
    • Appendix C. Ability and Accessibility in the Geosciences
    • Appendix D. Inclusive Committees Guide
    • Appendix E. Conference Guide
    • Appendix F. Seminar Guide
    • Appendix G. A guide to scientific authorship
    • Appendix H. Fieldwork Guide
  • Download Code of Conduct (PDF)

University of Texas Institute for Geophysics

J.J. Pickle Research Campus,
Building 196
10100 Burnet Road (R2200)
Austin, TX 78758-4445

Phone: 512-471-6156
Fax: 512-471-2370

Driving Directions

Connect with us

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

QUESTIONS?

frontdesk@ig.utexas.edu
or contact the webmaster
social@ig.utexas.edu

RESOURCES

Seismograms

Publications Database

Texas ScholarWorks

Travel Guide for UTIG Employees

Google Scholar

Facilities

HELPFUL LINKS

Directory (EID)

Job Listings

UTIG Fact Sheet

UTIG Brochure

UTIG Science Vision Plan

UTIG Newsletter

UTIG Code of Conduct

Commitment to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion

OUR PARTNERS

Bureau of Economic Geology

Department of Geological Sciences

Center for Planetary Systems Habitability

Visit the Jackson School's website

Copyright © 2022 University of Texas Institute for Geophysics
The University of Texas at Austin · Web Privacy Policy · Web Accessibility Policy